Compensation Considerations for Employer Retirement Contributions
By Mike Rahn, CISP
Many of our clients have a small business, and some maintain a SIMPLE IRA, SEP, or 401(k) plan. Some seem unsure of how to calculate compensation-based employer contributions to these plans. We avoid giving tax advice, but how can we help them with basic information on compensation for retirement plan contribution purposes?
Most tax-advantaged U.S. retirement plans provide for either mandatory or discretionary employer contributions. Some plans, like SIMPLE IRA and 401(k) plans, also permit employee salary deferrals. Employer contributions are typically made as a “match” of employee salary deferrals, or they can be “nonelective” contributions. The latter are not dependent on whether employees make salary deferral contributions. (Note: SEP plans established before 1997 can also permit employee salary deferrals,)
So how does an employee’s compensation affect these employer contributions?
An employer’s contributions are typically calculated and allocated according to a predetermined formula linked to employees’ annual compensation.
EXAMPLE 1: An employer with a SEP plan elects to provide a five percent contribution to all eligible employees. The dollar amount each employee receives will be calculated individually by multiplying an employee’s compensation by five percent. For example, an employee with annual compensation of $50,000 would receive a $2,500 employer SEP contribution.
EXAMPLE 2: SIMPLE IRA employer matching contributions will equal—or “match”—employee salary deferrals dollar-for-dollar, but only up to three percent of the employee’s compensation. An employee with $50,000 of annual compensation could receive up to $1,500 in matching contributions—three percent of their compensation. This would be the limit even if the employee deferred more than three percent. If he deferred less than three percent of his compensation, he would only receive an amount equal to his salary deferrals.
So how is that compensation determined?
Employees who are not business owners generally have their income reported on IRS Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement. This usually makes calculating an employer contribution very straightforward.
Can an employer tailor a plan’s definition of compensation to reflect the way its employees are paid, and to influence how their employer contributions will be calculated? For example, some employees receive bonuses, commissions, or certain fringe benefits, in addition to—or instead of—a base salary.
In the absence of approved language in a retirement plan’s governing document, all compensation reflected on IRS Form W-2 would generally be included. But many qualified retirement plans, including 401(k)s, do allow the employer to identify types of compensation—such as bonuses, commissions, overtime pay, etc.—that will or will not be included, but only within certain nondiscrimination parameters.
It is not typical to see such exclusions in a SIMPLE IRA or SEP plan, as most of these plans are established on IRS model or model-based plan documents, which have standard definitions of plan compensation. Some SEP prototype documents do allow employers to choose compensation definitions other than W-2 compensation, such as a definition that excludes the value of taxable fringe benefits.
Are there any other restrictions on compensation when determining contributions to a retirement plan?
Contributions can also be limited by the so-called “compensation cap” that generally applies to all retirement plans. It limits the amount of an employee’s compensation that can be taken into account when calculating employer contributions. For 2026 that amount is $360,000. Employee compensation above this amount must be disregarded.
For example, a five percent nonelective contribution must be calculated on no more than $360,000, even if an employee’s compensation is higher. An employee who earns $400,000 would receive a contribution of only $18,000 ($360,000 x .18), not $20,000, as would be the case if his full compensation was considered.
NOTE: The compensation cap does not apply to employer matching contributions made to a SIMPLE IRA plan.
Is determining compensation different if a retirement plan is new, or terminating, and thus covers only part of a year? For example, a SIMPLE IRA plan that is established on July 1, 2026, as opposed to January 1.
Yes. The previously-described compensation cap is prorated for a short plan year. For example, a new plan with a calendar year (all SIMPLE IRA plans are calendar-year) established on July 1 would have a six-month plan year. As a result, the 2026 compensation cap would be reduced to 50 percent—$180,000—for purposes of calculating employer nonelective contributions. (The annual limit for employee salary deferrals, $17,000 for those under age 50, is not prorated for a short plan year.)
Is determining compensation different for a business’s owner?
Sometimes. A business owner can be paid W-2 income, and commonly would be if that business is incorporated. But if the business is a sole proprietorship or a partnership, an owner’s compensation is determined differently.
For a sole proprietor, compensation for retirement plan purposes is calculated on Schedule C, Profit or Loss from Business, an attachment to IRS Form 1040, U.S. Individual Income Tax Return. (While it may seem obvious, it’s worth noting that a sole proprietor’s compensation for retirement plan purposes is not their adjusted gross income (AGI) from Form 1040, which may include both income and income adjustments that are unrelated to the business income determined on Schedule C.)
For a formal partnership, each partner’s income is identified on IRS Schedule K-1, Partner’s Share of Income, Deductions, Credits, etc., and provided to partners and submitted to the IRS with Form 1065, U.S. Return of Partnership Income. Form K-1 determines the compensation—up to the compensation cap—that will be considered for calculating employer contributions.
Key Take-away
Every employer, self-employed or otherwise, should rely on experienced tax or human resources expertise when determining compensation for retirement plan purposes. Getting this right is just as important as any other aspect of running a business.