The Same, Yet Different: Roth IRA vs. Roth 401(k), 403(b), and 457(b) Plans

By Mike Rahn, CISP

The concept of “pay now or pay later” is perhaps the most conspicuous difference between Roth IRAs and Traditional IRAs. The same holds true for pretax saving in 401(k) plans and similar deferral-type retirement plans, versus saving in Roth arrangements within these plans.

Pretax saving allows individuals to delay taxation on contributions and investment gains until the funds are distributed, either voluntarily or when they’re forced to take required minimum distributions (RMDs). In contrast, saving in Roth arrangements does not delay taxation, but—when certain requirements are met—all earnings will be distributed tax-free. And, with Roth savings, there are no forced distributions at any age.

While a Roth IRA and a Roth feature in an employer-sponsored retirement plan share the primary tax concept of “pay-now for tax-free earnings later”, there are some significant differences, not all of which are widely understood.

Income Matters with Roth IRAs

Eligibility to make Roth IRA contributions has always been income-dependent. Those with higher incomes may be restricted, or entirely prohibited, from making Roth IRA contributions. Why is this so?  Unlike Traditional IRAs, the Roth IRA benefit of tax-free earnings for savers has a long-term cost in revenue to the Treasury Department. This was recognized when Roth IRAs first became available as a savings arrangement in 1998. To limit this revenue loss, the ability to make Roth IRA contributions is incrementally phased out over specified income ranges. These income ranges differ for single individuals versus married couples, and are indexed for cost-of-living-adjustments (COLAs) from year to year.

There is also an option to convert pretax and nondeductible IRA assets to Roth status.

No Income Issue with Employer Plans

A very different scenario applies to Roth arrangements in employer-sponsored retirement plans. Employers with 401(k), 403(b), and governmental 457(b) plans may elect to offer Roth employer contributions, Roth salary deferrals, and pretax salary deferrals. But unlike Roth IRAs, one’s income does not limit the ability to make Roth salary deferrals. There is no phaseout of contribution eligibility as income rises. Apart from this obvious eligibility advantage is the much larger annual contribution permitted in an employer-sponsored retirement plan, including “catch-up” salary deferral contributions for those age 50 or older. (For 2026, eligible individuals age 50 and older can defer up to $32,500; individuals ages 60–63 can defer up to $35,750.)

Not all employers with such plans choose to offer the Roth option. But if they do, they must offer pretax salary deferrals, too. Like Roth IRAs, these plans may also offer the option to convert pretax and nondeductible amounts to Roth status, by means of an in-plan Roth rollover (IRR).

NOTE: A provision of the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 requires that all catch-up contributions for a participant whose FICA wages for the prior year exceed the “Roth catch-up wage threshold” be made on a Roth basis. As a result, participants whose 2025 FICA wages exceed $150,000 can only make Roth catch-up contributions for 2026 (FICA wages are reported in Box 3 of Form W-2).

When Can Individuals Withdraw Roth Savings?

A key difference between saving in a Roth IRA and saving in a 401(k), 403(b), or 457(b) plan is accessibility. Like Traditional IRAs, Roth IRA savings are available “on demand;” meaning, there are no regulatory restrictions on distributions.

This is not the case with Roth salary deferrals and their earnings in an employer plan. A statutory distributable event must take place before one can access amounts in these plans, regardless of whether they are pretax or Roth. These events include reaching age 59½, leaving employment with the plan-sponsoring employer, plan termination, and potentially—depending on the plan—employee hardship. (Unlike other distributable events, hardship distributions are not eligible for rollover to an IRA or to another retirement plan.)

Requirements for Tax-Free Earnings

Both Roth IRAs and Roth arrangements in employer plans provide tax-free earnings when an individual receives a “qualified distribution.”  To have a qualified distribution, both types of Roth arrangements require individuals to satisfy a five-year period and meet a secondary condition.

The Five-Year Clock

The five-year clock is specific to each separate employer plan that an individual participates in, unless he rolls over Roth assets from one employer plan to a new employer’s plan to continue the tolling of a five-year period. The five-year period for a Roth IRA is not plan-specific, but instead is taxpayer-specific. This means that any Roth IRA, opened at any time—with any custodian—begins the tolling of the Roth IRA five-year clock.

Of significance to plan participants who roll over Roth plan assets to a Roth IRA before earnings are tax-free, the Roth IRA five-year clock will determine the timing of tax-free status for those rolled-over earnings. It is therefore advantageous to establish even a minimally-funded Roth IRA if a person begins participating in a Roth 401(k), 403(b), or 457(b).

Employer Plan Roth Tax-Free Qualifying Events

In addition to satisfying the five-year clock, a 401(k), 403(b), or governmental 457(b) plan participant must meet one of the following conditions in order for Roth account earnings to be tax-free. The plan participant must

  • have attained age 59½,

  • be disabled, or

  • be deceased (earnings are tax-free to a beneficiary)

Roth IRA Tax-Free Qualifying Events

Roth IRA earnings are tax-free if the IRA owner satisfies the five-year requirement and meets one of the three conditions listed above, or one alternative condition: a first-time home buyer. This in turn requires that neither the IRA owner nor their spouse (if married) has owned a home during the prior two years. If so, $10,000 of Roth IRA earnings per taxpayer can be withdrawn tax and penalty-free. This is a lifetime limit.

Nonqualified Distribution Consequences

Any Roth IRA or employer plan Roth distribution that does not meet these dual requirements for tax-free earnings will result in taxation of earnings as ordinary income. They will also be subject to the 10 percent early distribution penalty tax if the recipient is not yet 59½ and has no other exception to the early distribution penalty tax.

Roth IRA vs Employer Plan Roth Distributions

Roth IRAs and Roth assets in employer plans differ markedly in their distribution rules with respect to contributions, converted pretax amounts, and earnings.

Roth IRA Distributions

Roth IRAs operate by what are called “ordering rules.”  All contributions—in aggregate, over all years—are distributed first. Next to be distributed are all amounts that have been converted from pretax to Roth status. Only after all contribution and conversion amounts have been distributed are earnings distributed.

This is extremely advantageous. Contribution amounts are always distributed tax and penalty-free. Conversion amounts are distributed tax-free but may be subject to the 10 percent early distribution penalty tax if they are distributed within five years of the conversion, the recipient is under age 59½, and no other penalty exception applies. The taxpayer is responsible for determining the nature and taxability of Roth IRA amounts distributed, calculated and reported on IRS Form 8606, Nondeductible IRAs.

Roth SEP and Roth SIMPLE Distributions

Roth SIMPLE IRA and Roth SEP plan contributions were made possible by the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022. Because these plans are IRA-based, distributions from them could generally be expected to follow Roth IRA ordering rules.

Unfortunately, IRS Notice 2024-2—the most detailed guidance on this option currently available—is brief and incomplete. It states that Roth salary deferrals are to be reported as taxable income on IRS Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement, and that employer contributions to SEP and SIMPLE IRAs are to be reported as if they were pretax amounts converted to Roth status. No reference has been made to reporting withdrawn amounts on IRS Form 8606, where Roth IRA contributions, conversions, and their earnings are reported when distributed. More to come, hopefully.

401(k), 403(b,) and 457(b) Plan Roth Distributions

Quite different are distributions from Roth 401(k), 403(b), and 457(b) plans. They are generally governed by basis recovery rules. This means that every distribution that is not “qualified,” and fully tax-free, will consist of proportionate (“prorated”) amounts of nontaxable amounts and taxable earnings in the account. The nontaxable amount consists of Roth deferrals, and—if present—amounts that have been converted from pretax to Roth status in an in-plan Roth rollover. If a recipient is not yet age 59½, and has no other exceptions, a 10 percent early distribution penalty tax will apply to the earnings portion of a nonqualified distribution.

NOTE: If a plan participant has both Roth deferrals and in-plan Roth rollovers, basis that is distributed in a nonqualified distribution is generally drawn first from available Roth deferral amounts, and then from in-plan Roth rollovers. Unless, that is—with proper separate accounting—a plan permits withdrawal of basis from in-plan Roth rollovers first. This can be advantageous if the participant is under age 59½ and still employed, a time when salary deferrals—including converted deferrals—are generally unavailable for distribution; whereas IRRs that consist of converted employer contributions may be distributable before age 59½.)

As with Roth IRAs, an in-plan Roth rollover is subject to a 10 percent “recapture” penalty if distributed within five years after the conversion, if the recipient is not yet age 59½ and has no other penalty tax exceptions. A separate five-year period applies to each tax year’s in-plan Roth rollovers.

Key Takeaways

Very few savings arrangements offer the prospect of generating tax-free earnings. Both Roth IRAs and Roth arrangements in employer retirement plans offer this benefit. But each has its own peculiarities, worth understanding when one makes that saving decision.